Carl-bot alternative
Carl-bot alternative for streamers on Discord
This page compares the Bearsong Discord bot with Carl-bot, with a link to the official Carl-bot page behind each Carl-bot fact. Bearsong is not affiliated with Carl-bot or BotLabs.
Carl-bot facts were checked against its official pages on 12 November 2026. Each one links to its source.
Bearsong at a glance
- The Bearsong Twitch bot and Discord bot are both turned on in Settings > Connections.
- Bearsong levels with role rewards do not need Premium.
- Bearsong posts when your own Twitch stream starts, changes category or ends, and can give you a live role.
- The Bearsong chat bridge shows your Twitch chat, raids and clips in a Discord channel.
- Fishing, crabbing and frogging progress is shared between Twitch chat and Discord for members who link their accounts.
Carl-bot at a glance
- Carl-bot tags are custom commands that can use TagScript.
- Carl-bot reaction roles have unique, binding, verify, drop and reversed modes, and temporary roles with Premium.
- Carl-bot sends YouTube upload alerts and live alerts for the Twitch streamers you add.
- Carl-bot Premium lets you upload a custom avatar and banner for the bot.
- Levels and XP earned with Carl-bot cannot be imported into Bearsong.
Bearsong and Carl-bot side by side
| Feature | Bearsong | Carl-bot |
|---|---|---|
| Welcome messages | Welcome and farewell messages as text or an embed, a join role and onboarding packs of roles. No Premium needed. Details | Welcome messages in a channel and a direct message on join, plus leave and ban messages. A separate farewell channel is a Premium command. Source |
| Reaction roles | Panels of buttons (up to 25 roles) or a select menu (up to 125), in Normal, Unique or Verify mode. No Premium needed. Details | 250 reaction roles per server on the free tier and 1,000 with Premium. Timed reaction roles need Premium. Source |
| Moderation and automod | Filters for phrases, invites and links, warnings that lead to a timeout, rules in Discord's AutoMod, anti-raid and verification. No Premium needed. Details | Automod with punishments from delete and warn to timeout, kick and ban, a warn threshold, spam settings and whitelisted channels and roles. Source |
| Levels and role rewards | XP for messages and voice time, level-up messages and roles at the levels you choose. No Premium needed. Details | 15 to 25 XP per message by default, level-up messages, level rewards and a leaderboard. The docs say Levels is a premium feature. Source |
| Server logs | Edited and deleted messages, joins and leaves, voice activity and channel and role changes, across up to six log channels. Details | Events logged to a channel you choose, which can be split across channels. /log aio creates a category with five log channels. Source |
| Twitch go-live posts | Posts when your own Twitch stream starts, changes category or ends, and can give you a live role. No Premium needed. Details | Live alerts for the Twitch streamers you add. Premium servers can add more streamers. Source |
| Automatic replies | Replies with text, an embed or a reaction when a message contains, matches, starts or ends with your words, plus smart replies. Details | Triggers that match part of a message, exact words, the whole message, or its start or end, with TagScript. A server can have 50, or 75 with Premium. Source |
| Where you set it up | The Bearsong app. Pick the server in the top bar and turn on each feature with its own switch. Details | The carl.gg dashboard, slash commands or mention commands. Prefix commands were disabled on 5 October 2026. Source |
Pricing
- Bearsong
- The core of Bearsong is free. Premium is coming soon and will be optional. What is free
- Carl-bot
- Carl-bot has a free tier and Premium, bought on Patreon or Discord. Its premium page does not show a price. A Discord subscription covers one server, and higher Patreon tiers cover more servers. Source
Move from Carl-bot to Bearsong
- Sign up, open Settings > Connections, turn on the Discord bot and accept its terms.
- Choose Add a Discord server, pick your server and approve the permissions Discord shows.
- In Discord's Server Settings > Roles, move the bot's role above every role it will give, such as your join role, reaction roles and level rewards.
- Set up each feature in Bearsong, turn on its switch for the server and test it in Discord.
- Bearsong posts its own role panels and cannot use an existing Carl-bot message. Create a panel in Bearsong, then delete the old message in Discord.
- In the Carl-bot dashboard, turn off each feature that Bearsong now does, so members do not get two messages for one event.
- When everything works, remove Carl-bot from your server.
Common questions
Is Bearsong free?
The core of Bearsong is free, and Premium is coming soon and will be optional. Levels, reaction roles, moderation, tickets and go-live posts do not need Premium.
Can I bring my Carl-bot levels and settings across?
No. Bearsong has no import from Carl-bot, and History & backups only adds settings files saved from Bearsong.
Can Bearsong post when other streamers go live?
No. Stream announcements post for the Twitch account you connect to Bearsong.
Do I need Twitch to use the Bearsong Discord bot?
No. Twitch is only needed for features that join the two, such as the chat bridge and stream announcements.
Is Bearsong part of Carl-bot?
No. Bearsong is not affiliated with Carl-bot or BotLabs.
Bearsong is not affiliated with Carl-bot, and the Carl-bot name belongs to its owner. Statements about Carl-bot come from its official pages as they read on 12 November 2026, and products change. If something here is out of date, tell us through Support and we will correct it.